Saturday, September 3, 2005

previous entry | main | next entry | TrackBack (1)


Milton Friedman, meet Robert Reich

Milton Friedman introduced the idea of a "negative income tax" in his 1962 book Capitalism and Freedom. The idea behind it was a way to provide welfare in the most efficient and least welfare-distorting manner possible.

In the New York Times today, Robert Reich drives this point home by looking at the deleterious effects of the alternative policy possibilities -- protectionism and pork-barrel spending:

Oil shocks, hurricanes and housing bubbles aside, consumers who are worried about their jobs and wages will be reluctant to buy goods and services, thereby dampening any recovery. But the new insecurity is undermining our national interest in other, less predictable ways by setting off political resistance to economic change, with negative repercussions that ripple beyond the economy.

Forty years ago, free-trade agreements passed Congress with broad backing because legislators recognized that they helped American consumers and promoted global stability. But as job and wage insecurity have grown, public support for free trade has declined. The North American Free Trade Agreement, which passed by 34 votes in 1993, was a hard sale for the Clinton administration. But the recent Central American Free Trade Agreement, embracing a far smaller and less populous area, was an even harder sale for President Bush. Despite Republican control of Congress, the trade deal cleared the House in July by just two votes, and then only after heavy White House pressure.

The increasing insecurity of ordinary workers also imperils our national defense by handcuffing the Pentagon. It can't shift the defense budget to fighting terrorism because of local fears that well-paying jobs will be lost. Contrast this with the comparative ease by which the Pentagon downshifted from fighting World War II to the cold war, more than 50 years ago. Its recent base-closing recommendations ignited a political firestorm, causing even the apolitical Base Closure and Realignment Commission to retreat. The commission's chairman justified its decision to save the Niagara Falls Air Reserve Station, for example, by noting that the base "is the second-largest employer in western New York."

Consider, finally, the pork that's been larded into the federal budget. Republicans may collectively oppose wasteful spending, but as individual legislators they've created more pork than any Congress in history. The new $286 billion transportation act is bloated with 6,371 "special projects" with a price tag some $30 billion more than the White House wanted. The president reassured the nation that it would, at the least, "give hundreds of thousands of Americans good-paying jobs." The new $12.3 billion energy bill cost twice what the White House sought because it's laden with what Senator Pete Domenici, the New Mexico Republican who ushered it through Congress, defends as measures to create "hundreds of thousands of jobs." According to the conservative watchdog group Citizens Against Government Waste, pork programs have risen from fewer than 2,000 a year in the mid-1990's to almost 14,000 this year.

Read the whole thing -- Reich proposes a number of policy possibilities, including the expansion of the modern-day equivalent of the negative income tax, the earned income tax credit.

I'm not sure I buy all of Reich's proposed package, but his analysis of the political economy of the status quo is dead on.

posted by Dan on 09.03.05 at 09:11 PM




Comments:

What did he do with all thesse bright ideas during the Clinton administration?

posted by: Mark on 09.03.05 at 09:11 PM [permalink]



@Mark:

According to Sid Blumenthal, Reich was busy strengthening the levees in New Orleans.

posted by: JK on 09.03.05 at 09:11 PM [permalink]




Two thoughts:

First, it is a shame that the jobs lost due to the taxes required to fund these "job-creating" projects are never counted. In many if not most cases, the net number of jobs will likely be negative. It is a shame too, that the politicians and bureaucrats, most but not all of whom understand this, feel so comfortable lying to the public.

Second, it is important to note that the EITC is very different from the NIT because it is a conditional transfer. You have to work to get the EITC. As such, it is not a substitute for programs such as TANF (pardon all the acronyms - that is how this area works) for single parents who are unwilling or unable to work. The NIT was proposed as an unconditional transfer - you have a pulse, you get it. The economics are therefore quite different.


Jeff Smith

posted by: Jeff Smith on 09.03.05 at 09:11 PM [permalink]



If Reich told me that the sky was blue, I'd go get a spectrophotometer and check his work.

posted by: Mitch H. on 09.03.05 at 09:11 PM [permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?





Politics, economics, globalization, academia, pop culture... all from a untenured tenured perspective

Main home page
Main blog page
About Me
Search My Blog
Favorite Blogs
Book Recommendations
Books of the Month (Summer 2006)






Reviews of DanielDrezner.com:

"Sharp but informal commentary on politics and foreign policy." -- The New Republic

"Dan Drezner is terrific.... Excellent blog." -- Andrew Sullivan

"Dan's stuff is always worth reading." -- Eugene Volokh

"One of the essential weblogs." -- gawker.com

"Monday morning quarterback... conservative robot... the very foundation of troubles in this country." -- not-so-random readers


Contact me at:
ddrezner@gmail.com
(But click here to read my e-mail policy)









Search the Site


Try advanced site search









Favorite Blogs

Glenn Reynolds
Andrew Sullivan
Mickey Kaus
Virginia Postrel
The Volokh Conspiracy
Josh Marshall
Crooked Timber
OxBlog
Real Clear Politics
Kevin Drum
Across the Aisle
TNR's The Plank
NRO's The Corner
TAP's Tapped
America Abroad
Duck of Minerva
Brad DeLong
Jeff Jarvis
Mystery Pollster
Mark Kleiman
Meryl Yourish
Megan McArdle
Marginal Revolution
Michael Munger
Chris Lawrence
Matthew Yglesias
Hit and Run
Cold Spring Shops
The Command Post
Stephen Green
Outside the Beltway
Pejman Yousefzadeh
Laura McKenna (11D)
Phil Carter
Joe Gandelman
Winds of Change
Andrew Samwick
Greg Mankiw
Roger L. Simon
Tom Maguire
Eric Zorn
Greg Djerejian
The American Scene
Post Global
Democracy Arsenal




Recent articles online

U.S. Trade Strategy: Free Versus Fair
Council on Foreign Relations Press, September 2006.

"The Trouble With Blogs."
Chronicle of Higher Education, July 28, 2006

"The Soccer Wars."
Washington Post, June 4, 2006

"More Harm Than Good."
Wall Street Journal, March 16, 2006

"Trade Talk."
The American Interest, Winter 2005

Complete online article archive




Blog Archives

October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003
July 2003
June 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003
December 2002
November 2002
October 2002
September 2002

Academia
Area studies
Book club
culture
economics
fence-sitting
from Blogger
globalization
homeland security
international relations
law
Mediasphere
My very important posts
New Republic
outsourcing
personal
politics
Sports
The blog paper
the blogosphere
Trade and Development
U.S. foreign policy
website maintenance

See full archives listing




Recent Entries

Those fools.... those tenured, bureaucratic fools
Maybe blogs and diplomacy don't mix too well
Your sexy sex quote of the day
Why Nancy Pelosi is the cure for all that ails us
So you think you know something about world politics
North Korea says they don't need no stinking tests
Does losing Tom Friedman mean losing middle america?
It's my virtual idea!! Mine!! Mine!!
From now on, when you hear "Drezner," think of strength, security... and minty freshness!!
What if the Dems take over the Congress?




Site Credits